Tuesday, January 1, 2013

Who should eat gluten free?

     Lately the gluten free diet has been in the news. There are many people following this diet for a variety of reasons. For those who are curious as to what exactly a gluten free diet is, I thought I would write a post giving a bit of background and maybe some glimpses into the future.
     First, a bit of a definition of what gluten IS: gluten is the protein found in wheat, rye and barley. Often oats can be CONTAMINATED with wheat, so many celiacs stay away from it. There are gluten-free [quality tested]oats on the market, but some celiacs cannot tolerate those oats either. It is this protein that makes regular breads soft and doughy. This is often times why gluten free items are so dense
     The one group that ABSOLUTELY has to eat gluten free are those with celiac disease. Celiac disease is not an allergy- rather it is an autoimmune disease. [There is a wheat allergy, which also requires an absolute swearing off of wheat, but not necessarily rye and barley.] This disease causes the body to attack itself, specifically the small villi that line the intestine. Because these villi are the primary receptors that process the nutrients from your food, celiac patients experience a whole host of symptoms. As I explain to others, your body works together as a machine- when something is missing or off, it affects the rest of your body. There are many symptoms, but some of the common one are gastrotintestinal issues, anemia [which leads to fatigue], headaches, infertility, and even hair loss. University of Chicago Celiac Disease Center says that 1 in 133 people in the Unites States has celiac disease, although 97 percent do not know it. Celiac disease is a genetic disorder, so it is very important to have all family members tested if you are celiac.
      The next group that should stay away from gluten is those who are gluten sensitive. This is harder to diagnose, and many researchers are working on away to pinpoint a way to diagnose it. [There is no genetic or blood test at this time like there is with Celiac disease.] The main way to determine if this is best for you is to work with a doctor and do a gluten challenge, which involves removing gluten COMPLETELY from your diet for a period, then reintroducing it to see if symptoms recur. Again, I am not a doctor or nurse, so this is why it is important to talk to your doctor about this before making any dietary changes. [Actually, if you have not been tested for celiac disease first, do NOT change your diet, because to be tested for CD they test for the antibodies in your blood that are reacting to the gluten, so it is important not to change your diet.]
       There is some evidence, both anecdotal and research driven, that the gluten free diet can benefit other disorders. One autoimmune disorder [like celiac disease] is a gateway to other autoimmune disorders. There is some suggestion that a gluten free diet is beneficial for those with Sjoegren's Disease, Multiple Sclerosis, and Lupus- all those PLEASE note. It is mentioned that Celiac Disease can be linked to these diseases, and that going on a gluten free diet helps with the celiac disease, which in turn makes the patient feel better. In my humble opinion, I think anyone with an autoimmune disease should be tested for celiac disease. It's a very simple blood test.
       There is also anecdotal evidence that those suffering with Autism benefit from  a gluten-free casein-free diet. [Casein is the protein in dairy products- not to be confused with lactose, which is the sugar found in dairy.]  I've read several articles from parents who say that their children have a complete turn around. Last I knew there was some controversy, as not everyone agrees about this. All I know is this- I have a strong suspicion that many of the illnesses that we are experiencing are due to the food that we are eating- either because we have allergies or because of pesticides and genetically modified foods Nutrition is SO very important.
      There is also a book out there called The Wheat Belly Diet, in which a doctor believes that gluten is the mastermind behind the obesity epidemic that we have. As a celiac, I've had to ponder some of this. Many celiacs at first are angry to be honest, because people following a gluten free diet to lose weight don't have the major health consequences if they accidentally ingest it. It makes it harder for restaurants to understand what is really going on, as well as manufacturers of gluten free foods Cross contamination is a tricky and important issue. My guess is that many of these people may be gluten-sensitive.
    Above all, there are a few very important things for those following a gluten free diet to remember.
        1) Read all labels carefully. Gluten sneaks into items in many ways. If at all possible, frequently purchase items that specifically say gluten free on them, and even better support companies that support the Celiac Sprue Association or other celiac organizations.
         2) Nutrition is SO very important. Make sure you eat whole grains as much as possible, eat lots of fruits and vegetables [so you can get your fiber], drink your water, and get your calcium, either from dairy, greens, or supplements. [Some people say celiacs should stay away from dairy as well - personally I'm not sold on that yet.]
         3) Back to the whole grains- wheat, rye and barley and loaded with whole grains, i.e, endosperm and bran, where your B vitamins are located. These B vitamins are INCREDIBLY important- they regulate your metabollism, your sleep, controls your blood sugar, and makes your white blood cells to build your immune system. This is where the issue comes in- many gluten free grains are heavily processed and are short in whole grains, and are not fortified like regular grains, cereals, and pastas. If you are choosing to eat gluten free- YOU must make sure to get your  B vitamins from grains that are gluten free. Examples are amaranth, millet, teff, buckwheat [ which is actually related to rhubarb], and quinoa. Oh yeah, and brown rice.

         So this was an incredibly long post, I know. But hopefully it was helpful. In general, if you have any auto-immune disease, including Type 1 diabetes, you should be tested for celiac disease. If you think you may be gluten-sensitive, please consult with a doctor first. And if you choose to eat gluten-free, eating nutritiously is highly important. I even suggest meeting with a dietician.

3 comments:

  1. Unfortunately, I'm new at this blogging thing. Someone sent me a reply comment, and I accidentally erased it. (Sorry Phil!) So I will copy and paste what he wrote-

    "Hi Margaret!

    First I wanted to point out that the connection between autism and gluten ingention is not purely anecdotal. It has been studied, and gluten's effect on mental health was written out over 50 years ago, with respect to schizophrenia. Here is one like where they talk about gluten and it's effect on the brain, including autism.
    http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dr-david-perlmutter-md/gluten-impacts-the-brain_b_785901.html

    Also, the Wheat Belly Diet isn't about losing weight. It centers on the fact that no ones body can digest wheat, it causes leakey gut, it impacts the brain, it causes a number of disorders, and it spikes blood suger more than candy. Even though he does allow certain grains to be consumed in small quantites, his stance is the entire "Whole Grain" diet is a farce, and no one should be eating them at all. This is also the stance of the Paleo diet and the Gluten Free Society. "

    -Thank you Phil in writing back to me. I am cautious in what I write, especially about the autism, because I am not a doctor or nurse and I know that there is reaserach out there that I am unfamiliar with. Thank you for sharing your research.
    Also, thank you for sharing your viewpoints about the Wheat Belly Diet. I have never read the book, and only know from what I have seen in the news or heard from those trying it. So thank you for your insight.
    In this blogpost, I was simply trying to explain different reasons as to why some people are trying to eat gluten free, and why it may benefit them. My major concern is that people are still getting all the nutrients that they need, as eating gluten free CAN cause nutritional deficiencies.

    Again, thanks for writing, and I hope more people comment. I promise I'll try not to delete it next time! :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. I wanted to find out more about this "Wheat belly" diet, having lived with a celiac for 10 years. I went to the website, and it seems mostly like a way to promote books. Maybe it is, but the book could have good info, right? Well, I found a review of it here (http://noglutennoproblem.blogspot.com/2012/03/wheat-belly-busted.html) that sure seems to point out some flaws.

    I even went to the "counterattack" portion of the wheat belly blog,(http://www.wheatbellyblog.com/category/wheat-belly-counterattacks/) and the mocking tone that it took with a Food Network blog was disgusting, comparing anyone who eats wheat to alcoholics. The Food Network blog also has a link to a scientific journal article that takes claims from Wheat Belly and analyzes them point by point. (http://www.aaccnet.org/publications/plexus/cfw/pastissues/2012/OpenDocuments/CFW-57-4-0177.pdf)

    Anyway, I think that the reaction this gets from supporters of Dr. Davis is bordering on fanaticism. I understand that it may work for some people, but that doesn't mean that there aren't legitimate criticisms of his work. I'm going to continue to eat my whole-grain, whole wheat bread and crackers as part of my food plan. Please don't accuse me of being an addict in denial, and I won't call you a brainwashed fanatic.

    ReplyDelete
  3. As someone that has been practicing a wheat-free, whole grain free existence since December of 2012, I can say that I am stronger, healthier, more fit, AND slimmer since removal of all grains from my diet, with the exception of an occasional small amount of rice.

    I did not embark upon the wheat belly diet for the purpose of losing weight, (I already know how to do that with the inclusion of wheat!)but for the pursuit of wellness.

    I won't go into all of the intimate details of my intestinal disorders, brain fog, fatigue, etc. but I will tell you that after practicing this plan some amazing things have occurred: 1) I can truly say for the first time in my life I am no longer addicted to bread and the like - and my diet has been transformed from carb-based to protein-vegetable based. 2) all - ALL of my digestion issues have been resolved. 3) My blood sugar counts have lowered dramatically and I no longer suffer the roller coaster of hyper-hypoglycemia. 4) I have lost a significant amount of weight rather easily.

    Yes, you are right Margaret....I am not Celiac (as I have been tested) but I do believe I have a level of gluten intolerance that as had ill effects on my body. I am sorry that some of the Celiac community feels "anger" at the thought of people jumping on the gluten-free bandwagon, but to be quite honest, it if helps persons achieve wellness, why begrudge them?

    I am a firm believer that food is our best medicine..and food can be our worst evil. I know now how important it is to eat whole, non-gmo foods (I can't believe I have been transformed!) and stop eating what BIG FOOD tells us is healthy. After all, they just want to make a buck.

    As for all of the gluten-free products available, I don't partake in them either. I can live without muffins, cake, pies, and bread. I don't need sugar, either. I find that so many gluten-free products, in an attempt to replace wheat gluten, are not the most healthy products either. Just my humble opinion.

    I personally get angry when I realize that the push for wheat (and it's addictive properties) comes from the USDA and ADA suggesting that today's wheat is good for us! Ask yourself, why is wheat in so many processed food products? Without a doubt because of it's addictive qualities. Betcha can't eat just one.

    Thanks for listening and I appreciate your thoughts.

    ReplyDelete